Revisiting the discussion
November 20, 2026
Six months and two surveys later, Bowdoin students are still asking the same question. The data from the Fall 2026 and Spring 2026 Bowdoin Orient Student Survey’s (BOSS) both show that approximately two-thirds of respondents think Bowdoin should have an official hate speech policy.
While the College has guidelines concerning freedom of expression, they do not explicitly address hate speech, leaving students without a clear standard for what the College considers unacceptable. The most recent change in Bowdoin’s freedom of expression policy was about postering, building use and demonstrations.
In February, following incidents of racist and Islamophobic rhetoric on campus and conversations with affinity group leaders, Bowdoin Student Government (BSG) called for an amendment to the College’s social code explicitly prohibiting hate speech.
“It is past time that our social code directly condemns hate speech. Fixing this omission demonstrates our resolve as a collective student body in standing up to hate in all its forms. To this end, we are advocating to the Deans for a section of the Bowdoin Code of Conduct that explicitly bans hate speech,” BSG wrote in its February statement.
Among the affinity group leaders involved in these discussions was Black Student Union President Jickinson Louis ’26, who addressed the issue in an opinion piece. “There is a stark difference between intellectual disagreement and hate speech. Intellectual debate relies on challenging ideas while respecting one’s humanity, whereas hate speech is a rhetorical process that denies moral worth and agency,” Louis wrote.
Moreover, Louis provided readers with advice on how confronting hate starts with institutional policy, but requires a collective responsibility to recognize and challenge prejudice within our community.
“A great community is not defined by its aversion to confronting hate but by its ability to name hate confidently. Hate does not begin with violence. It begins when some people’s fear is acceptable, when some words are harmless and when some communities are expendable,” he wrote.
Other student voices have argued against hate speech policies. In 2011, Jose Cespedes claimed in his Orient column that such codes punish students unfairly.
“The College is fully within its rights as a private institution to ignore certain constitutional rights, and with regards to free speech, it has clearly chosen to exercise that privilege,” Cespedes wrote. “The policy leads to the unfair prosecution of students and keeps important intellectual discussions superficial and politically correct.”
Legally, Bowdoin has room to discuss this issue. The First Amendment restricts public institutions from censoring speech, even if it is deeply offensive or bigoted. This is why public universities are often unable to punish hate speech if it stops short of harassment or direct threats. Bowdoin College, as a private institution, is not held to the same standards and can answer to its own commitments of expression. Whether the College updates its policies is a question for the community.
Student demands should be met and the conversation around hate speech should be revisited. These conversations should not occur behind closed doors; rather, there should be an open forum for students to be included throughout the whole process.
This editorial represents the majority opinion of the Editorial Board.
Comments
Before submitting a comment, please review our comment policy. Some key points from the policy: