Go to content, skip over navigation

Sections

More Pages

Go to content, skip over visible header bar
Home News Features Arts & Entertainment Sports OpinionAbout Contact Advertise

Note about Unsupported Devices:

You seem to be browsing on a screen size, browser, or device that this website cannot support. Some things might look and act a little weird.

@nescacbarstool and the perpetuation of toxic masculinity at Bowdoin and beyond

October 27, 2017

This piece represents the opinion of the author.

On October 8, the Instagram account @nescacbarstool posted for the first time. The account’s debut was a video proclaiming that in the NESCAC, “we work hard but we play harder.” The clip is a montage of partying crowds at various schools and concludes with a sped-up video of a student vomiting into a trash can, red solo cup in hand. Subsequent posts feature videos of students streaking the quad at Wesleyan, someone slapping a woman’s glitter-covered backside at Williams—in slow motion—and a student at Middlebury shotgunning a beer before promptly turning around to have a person behind the camera shoot a dart into his back.

@nescacbarstool thrives on the audience’s acceptance of its posts as displays of benign debauchery. The events, which we witness from the removed comfort of our smartphone screens, are intended to glorify the “savagery” of their predominantly male participants. With thousands of views, likes and followers, @nescacbarstool appears to succeed in spreading the word that the bookish coeds of the NESCAC can party just as hard as their state school counterparts.

Bowdoin students are well represented on the account, as there are multiple videos of Bowdoin students engaging in all kinds of drunken antics. Multiple videos show students smashing beer cans on their heads in order to open them, and there is even a clip of a student drinking beer by funneling it through a gory fish head. Though these videos are seemingly harmless, the underlying ethos of the account is the glorification of male aggression fueled by excessive drinking.

Our student body and administration are outwardly dedicated to gender equality. Actions like this week’s Take Back the Night event and administrative efforts at providing recourse to victims of sexual violence are examples in which the school has taken a strong stand against the patriarchy. But we would be remiss to ignore the toxic masculinity that pervades Bowdoin’s social scene into the present day. The integration of women into the student body, as well as the abolition of the fraternity system, are both seen as watershed moments of progress in Bowdoin’s history. These historical moments, however, are more symbolic than emblematic of fundamental changes to campus culture.

At its most benign, Bowdoin’s male-centric social scene still gives way for shenanigans not wholly unlike those that occurred half a century ago. @nescacbarstool’s posts provide ample evidence to support this point. At its most insidious, Bowdoin’s social scene perpetuates the continued objectification of women. Rather than being bused from neighboring colleges on the weekend, as they were before the days of coeducation, women on this campus are instead faced with constant but often subtle reminders of their inferiority. Popular social media accounts like @nescacbarstool and a similar account, @nescacsmokeshows, feature posts about attractive women from different NESCAC schools. And instances of sexual harassment and assault have become so prevalent and normalized that the baseline expectation is that every woman at Bowdoin has a “story.”

@nescacbarstool and all its troubling content can serve as an important jumping-off point for discussion about the negative effects of hypermasculinity at Bowdoin. On October 19, The New York Times posted a video compiling the multiple instances in which Harvey Weinstein’s transgressions towards women were jokingly referenced in pop culture. The video begs the viewer to wonder what would have happened if Weinstein had been exposed and reprimanded sooner. It also encourages viewers to become more observant consumers of culture and asks them to be more skeptical of what is presented to them as normal or innocuous. Drawing from these lessons, we should heed @nescacbarstool’s public warnings of an unhealthy campus culture, rather than laugh at this behavior and grant it validation online.

Advertisement

More from Opinion:

Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

Catch up on the latest reports, stories and opinions about Bowdoin and Brunswick in your inbox. Always high-quality. Always free.

Comments

Before submitting a comment, please review our comment policy. Some key points from the policy:

  • No hate speech, profanity, disrespectful or threatening comments.
  • No personal attacks on reporters.
  • Comments must be under 200 words.
  • You are strongly encouraged to use a real name or identifier ("Class of '92").
  • Any comments made with an email address that does not belong to you will get removed.

2 comments:

  1. Johnson L. says:

    Though I’m not condoning reckless debauchery, I’m wondering where you make the connection between smashing beer cans on foreheads and sexual violence. I think comparing any content from @nescacbarstool to Weinstein’s actions is pretty egregious and borderline offensive to the individuals in the videos.

    I’m not saying sexual violence and toxic masculinity don’t exist at Bowdoin, far from it. I’m open to hearing why you think that partying is a reminder to women about their inferiority.

  2. ConcernedBowdoinSupporter says:

    “But we would be remiss to ignore the toxic masculinity that pervades Bowdoin’s social scene into the present day.”
    “important jumping-off point for discussion about the negative effects of hypermasculinity at Bowdoin.”
    Apparently some students are still allowed to express their thinly veiled venom and hate for whole categories of other students. After seeking out and viewing random affronts on line, a student feels justified in bitterly lashing out at half her fellow students. Talk about a hostile environment. Maybe Bowdoin should start talking about the toxic effect of man hating before it is too late. There are plenty of ways that men could improve, but this won’t do it and men aren’t the only people in need of improvement. Women are already earning nearly 60% of the bachelor’s degrees these days. Does anyone believe society will be better if we drive half of its members to check out? Women—if you don’t like what that guy is doing, leave the party or don’t invite him again. And certainly don’t ruin your night by watching it on video! Let’s not squander our current opportunity to right injustice by turning into angry shrews.


Leave a Reply

Any comments that do not follow the policy will not be published.