Students packed into a standing-room-only Beam Classroom in the Visual Arts Center on Wednesday to hear a presentation from their peers and professors on the appropriation of Native American culture.
According to Dean of Multicultural Affairs Leana Amaez, at least one instance of cultural appropriation occurs each year, often by students who dress in “native” costumes for Halloween or a themed party. These instances are not always limited to Native American attire; she noted that earlier in the fall semester students wearing sombreros were brought to her attention.
When these instances of appropriation occur, Amaez often begins a dialogue with students that focuses not on their intentions, but on the impact their actions had on fellow students. “If the problem is ignorance, then the solution is education,” said Amaez, noting that repercussions rarely take the form of punishment.
The event was facilitated by Zohran Mamdani ’14.
Bowdoin Student Government president Sarah Nelson ’14 opened the discussion by recounting an experience last fall where she attended a costume party dressed as a Native American woman.“When I met with the Dean’s office later that week and heard how hurtful my actions had been to some of my peers, I was embarrassed, horrified and surprised,” she said. “That I had owned a costume for six years and was so ignorant to the fact that it was a misappropriation of someone else’s culture—someone else’s identity—terrified me.”
She went on to explain that she believes awareness education can help other students to think about these issues in a new way.
“I hope that, in listening to my story about a time when I made a serious error, everyone here will be more willing to talk to their peers, especially their peers of different races and ethnicities, about where the holes in our understandings of each other’s identities lie,” she said.
First year Dylan Goodwill introduced herself to the crowd and identified herself a member of the Navajo, Lakota and Dakota tribes; she grew up on the Window Rock Navajo Reservation in St. Michaels, Arizona.
“I’ve grown up with a sense of following my traditional ways—going to ceremonies and living in a hogan, which is the traditional Navajo home,” said Goodwill. “I’ve grown up dancing pow wow since I was two years old.”
She explained that some stereotypically native symbols often used by non-natives in costumes hold deep importance within the Native American community.
“We grew up knowing that the way we dress, the way our hair was, our moccasins, our turquoise, our feathers were all sacred and that everything had a meaning,” she said.
For instance, for Goodwill, eagle feathers symbolize “protection and harmony,” among other things, and she currently has eagle feathers hanging in her dorm room to remind her of this. She explained that seeing these symbols being used by people who had no connection to them was hurtful.
“They’re not costumes. We call them regalia,” said Goodwill. “It’s not something that we’re trying to hide from ourselves—it’s something that we are.”
Assistant Professor of Sociology Ingrid Nelson and Assistant Professor of Anthropology Kelly Fayard brought an academic lens to the talk. Professor Nelson explained that the work the teach-in was doing was not about “blame or shame or guilt,” but bringing an awareness of each person’s privilege, which shapes experiences and grants advantages that often go unseen. She encouraged students to “use the privilege that you have to dismantle systems that perpetuate that privilege.” Fayard, a member of the Poarch Band of Creek Indians, detailed the long history of cultural appropriation of Native American images in America. She showed images from the Boston Tea Party, secret societies at Yale and the University of Michigan, professional sports teams logos and fashion that all took symbols from Native American culture.
These stereotypes, in Fayard’s view, are damaging to Native American groups on many levels. She noted that they consistently grouped all Native cultures together without an appreciation for the varied practices of the more than 500 federally recognized Native American tribes. “[Stereotypes] constantly put natives as part of the past,” she added. “It basically erases the existence of modern Native American peoples.”
She encouraged students to buy from Native American designers if they are interested in Native American patterns or traditional jewelry, instead of mass marketed products that proport themselves to be native.
After the presentations, students posed questions to the panelists on how to discuss issues of appropriation with peers who may not understand the issue. One topic that was repeated was the use of Native American figures as mascots in professional sports.
Ben Woo Ching, a sophomore who identifies as American Samoan, noted that these issues can often exist in a gray area.
“The University of Hawaii is the Hawaiian Warriors and that’s okay for them because they’re in Hawaii but it is not okay [when] a white man owns the Atlanta Braves,” he said.
Woo Ching thought the discussion reflected W. E. B. DuBois’ double consciousness, in that “White only perceives as white perceives but the minority perceives from both directions.”
Amaez hopes that more discussions of race and identity can continue in a student-led platform. Next fall, she will begin a training program for students interested in facilitating discussions about race for peers. Plans for this program will be finalized over the summer.
Vacant frat house at 38 Harpswell Road to be demolished on Monday
Thirty-eight Harpswell Road, the former Alpha Kappa Sigma fraternity house, is slated for demolition starting this Monday, November 25. The College has yet to finalize plans for the lot.
“We don’t have a timetable or design for the new structure, but we hope it’s in the next few years,” said Senior Vice President for Finance and Administration and Treasurer Katy Longley. According to Longley, proposals for the space have included an arctic museum with additional classroom space.
Now known as Lancaster House, the College acquired the building along with several other former fraternity houses in June 2000.
IT targets students’ personal Wi-fi hubs
Unauthorized access points slow network, pose security risk, says IT
According to Director of Networking and Telecommunications Jason Lavoie, over 25 unauthorized Wi-fi access points have been installed since the beginning of the academic year, mainly in dorms, and are now causing problems with the network as a whole.
According to Chief Information Officer Mitch Davis and Lavoie, this has resulted in poorer service for the rest of the community.
Though Information Technology (IT) could turn off the unauthorized access points on their own, Davis said he hopes to instead encourage collaboration between students and IT in tackling this issue, a sentiment he outlined in an email to the college on November 15.
Nine safety violations in Dining since 2010
No violations represented extreme safety risks; Dining reports that they see inspections as a learning tool.
Since 2010, food safety inspectors from the Maine Department of Health and Human Services have issued nine Risk Factor/Intervention Violations to Dining Service’s four food service locations at Bowdoin: four in Thorne, three in Moulton, two in Jack Magee’s Pub & Grill, and none in the Café. None of these violations represented extreme risks to the quality or safety of the food served to Bowdoin students.
According to Ken Cardone, the associate director and executive chef of dining services who has been at Bowdoin for 25 years, Dining sees these inspections as learning tools rather than punishment.
“When you have an inspection report, [the inspector will] call attention to certain areas,” Cardone said. “We make those adjustments quickly, and that helps as a training tool.”
Student research warns of rising midcoast sea levels; community officials respond
Rising sea levels caused by global climate change could have a serious effect on towns in midcoast Maine, according to research presented by Cam Adams ’14 at the “Changing Tides: Perspectives on Sea Level Rise” panel last week.
Since hearing about the research last year, midcoast community officials in Bath and Bowdoinham have launched further analyses of the data.
Organized by Courtney Payne ’15, Anna Hall ’15, and Margaret Lindeman ’15, the November 14 panel looked at the potential effects of sea level rise as a result of climate change on the international, state and local levels.
594 ED I apps; 20% more countries represented
High school students hoping to enroll at Bowdoin next fall have begun to send their applications, essays, recommendation letters and arts supplements to the Office of Admissions. The College received 594 applications for Early Decision I (ED I). The deadline was last Friday, November 15.
The number of ED applications may fluctuate in the coming days, according to Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid Scott Meiklejohn. Some students will opt to switch to regular decision, and some students who have already applied regular will call to move their application into the ED pool.
The number of applications is fairly consistant with previous years. It marks a slight decrease from the record-breaking 602 ED applications for the Class of 2017.
Sixty minutes: investigating the Common Hour tradition
Six Fridays a semester, Bowdoin students, faculty and staff gather in order “to rejoice in our collegiate purpose, to interact with each other, and to deepen our common understanding, concern and delight.” Common Hour—set aside for the entire community—brings speakers on a wide range of topics to address the Bowdoin community.
Students, faculty and staff choose five out of the six Common Hour speakers for each semester through an open nomination process. The remaining speaker is chosen from the faculty via student nominations only. The annual number of nominations varies, ranging from as few as 10 to as many as 100.
Once the nominations are submitted, the Office of Events and Summer Programs, under the guidance of Associate Director of Events and Summer Programs Brenna Hensley, reviews them all individually and check for speakers that have multiple nominations or that people have shown high degrees of interest in. Hensley and her team research potential speakers, check their availability, and if everything falls into place, invite them to speak.
No major issues with Polaris rollout
Eight percent more students received their first choice classes with Polaris compared to the old paper system.
This week marked the first time the entire student body used Polaris, the new online course registration website, rather than course cards. First years used Polaris for course selection this fall.
Registrar Jan Brackett evaluated Polaris’ success from two angles: what the results were for students signing up for classes and what feedback she received from the faculty and advisors.
“I compared how many people were in four classes after round one versus how many people were in four classes after the top of the card was processed last spring,” when registration was still done on paper, Brackett said. By this metric, all four grade levels did better this spring using Polaris than last spring with paper registration cards, so she “consider[s] that a success.”
BSG Update: BSG discusses Saturday pep rally, active bystander training
Bowdoin Student Government (BSG) met this Wednesday, primarily to review the progress of previously approved mandates before departure for Thanksgiving break next week.
Vice President for Academic Affairs Jordan Goldberg ’14 discussed an event occurring on campus last night called “Difference at Bowdoin.”
The event featured two guest speakers, Jeff Cuartas ’14 and H. Roy Partridge, a visiting professor of sociology, and examined difference and diversity on Bowdoin’s campus. Goldberg also noted the success of the ‘Food for Thought’ talks held this past Monday in the Hawthorne-Longfellow Library.
Emails: From Allen Delong: Pep rally cancellation
- November 15
McLellan renovations to cost town 10 times initial estimate
As Bowdoin prepares to move its offices from the first and second floor of the McLellan Building by Hannaford to various locations on campus, the Town of Brunswick is debating how to pay for the building’s higher-than-expected renovation costs.
At a meeting last Thursday, the Brunswick Town Council discussed possibilities for financing the renovation of the building, located at 85 Union St., which they estimate will cost nearly $1 million. The town plans to use the building as a new town hall.
“A lot of this discussion has arisen because the price has escalated,” said town councilor Benet Pols.
Editorial: Feedback loop
With less than three weeks left in the fall semester, the final push is upon us. And though we’ve known about many of these final assignments since the first day of classes, these last papers, exams and projects never fail to induce panic, culminating in December’s all-too-familiar—and almost always over- caffeinated—frenzied final sprint. What we produce in these last three weeks represents, in theory, a demonstration of a semester’s worth of lectures, readings and assignments—a synthesis of all we’ve learned. Yet we tend to dispatch these completed assignments into a void, abandoning them as we pack our bags for our long-awaited break.
Currently, there is no official policy for professors handing back graded finals and papers. And though some do offer students the option of turning in final work along with a self-addressed envelope, or encourage them to collect assignments at the start of the following semester, this is far from the norm. More often than not, the quality of our final work is reflected in the course grade alone; students rarely ask for—and thus miss out on—constructive feedback.
It would be disingenuous to suggest that grades are irrelevant, or that the hard work we do throughout the semester is reflective of pure intellectual zeal. Grades are powerful external motivators. But this reality does not negate the fact that learning for learning’s sake is folded into our work as well. We benefit from working on these assignments, and we owe it to ourselves to bring the process full circle.
- 1 days ago
Deal with it: Don’t snooze your alarm: build mental discipline doing what you hate
The unnamed dad in the Calvin and Hobbes comic series had a popular refrain. Whenever Calvin complained about something (usually a father-son bonding activity) his dad always responded with a because-I-said-so reason, followed by, “Besides, it builds character.” The importance of these character-building moments in our lives should not be understated.
As long as I can remember my family motto has been “suck it up.” I have come to realize that through their mildly ostensible harshness, my parents were trying to do me a favor. Not only do excruciating experiences—such as airport hang overs on international flights—make someone a more versed and interesting individual, they also contribute to the stock of mental discipline.
Before proceeding, I think it is wise to actually define ‘mental discipline.’ I see it as the ability to muster the willingness to do something that is undesirable, but ultimately necessary or beneficial. Ending a Netflix binge and getting back to work, resisting a third helping of pie at Bowdoin’s Thanksgiving dinner, and showing up to class on Friday morning (shudder) all in some way require varying degrees of mental toughness.
- 1 days ago
In support of the right to bare all
Not all nudity is sexual. We’re born naked (duh); we give birth naked; we bathe naked; we have to get naked (or semi-naked) at the doctor’s office. And there is also an elusive subculture of nudity at Bowdoin. We all know about naked laps: you lose too hard at beer pong and you have to run around the building naked. There is the tradition of streaking the quad because this is a college. Balls to Mass Hall (i.e. sprinting from Hubbard to Mass Hall) is a trek. When I did it, three quarters of the way through an unbidden complaint popped into my head: “When is this gonna be over?" But I didn’t confess that I found streaking boring.
Then there are the naked parties. I wound up at one last year. I remember being struck by how visible everything was. It was in the Tower and the space had that stark, stale Tower feeling. The fluorescent lights concealed nothing and I was amazed by the range of bodies. Fat bodies and skinny bodies. Boobs of all different sizes. Bodies with tattoos and piercings (I drunkenly read aloud Bible verses off my physics tutor’s back). They were, to my memory, all white bodies, but that’s a different conversation.
Different levels of nudity were accepted—I decided to keep my underwear on. Most people were entirely naked, though. In describing it later I remembered how many drunk, cold, flaccid penises there were. So hats off to all those dudes who were brave enough to let it fly. After about half an hour, my friend and I put our clothes back on (they had been stored in trash bags graciously provided by the host) and left feeling good about our bodies and the accepting nature of our peers.
- 1 days ago
all out of love: Insurance woes: Obamacare proving ineffective
106,856. That is the number of people who successfully selected—not bought—a new healthcare plan this past October under the Obama administration’s legislation often referred to as ‘Obamacare.’ The program’s official name is the Affordable Care Act (ACA), a moniker that now seems ironic, given recent struggles.
A mere 27,000 people dove into the behemoth website that is healthcare.gov and emerged having successfully selected a plan. For those in need of a refresher, healthcare.gov is the federal government’s version of a highly touted new-age online marketplace; the particulars of the ACA were centered on the assumption of its functionality. In Maine, a state that opted to use the federal government’s website, only 271 people selected a plan by the end of the month.
As kindly noted by Rep. Steve Stockman of Texas, more people caught chlamydia last month than selected a plan under Obamacare. He also noted that more people followed Nickelback on Twitter, and bought Yoko Ono’s first album than selected a plan.
- 1 days ago
Home In All Lands: Helmet head: your brain is worth the investmentWhenever I see groups of visitors being led around campus on admissions tours, I wonder about the kinds of things that they must notice as they walk around Bowdoin’s campus. What do they think about the Quad? Do they think—as I do—that Smith Union is a little too bright and its colors a little too garish? Are they frightened by the thunder of basketball being played in Sargent Gym? They inevitably will start thinking about the cost of going to a school like Bowdoin. Going to college in the United States isn’t cheap; Bowdoin is certainly no exception. So you will forgive my surprise when I see people racing around campus at breakneck speeds, endangering the brains they have invested in so dearly: helmet-wearing cyclists are few and far between at Bowdoin. “Well if they don’t need to use their brains, they don’t need helmets!” quipped one professor who always wears a helmet when cycling. If we assume that the cost of a Bowdoin education is related to the value of your brain, then your cerebral matter is quite valuable indeed. For argument’s sake, let’s say that four years at Bowdoin costs $200,000. And let’s just say that this represents the approximate value of your brain. If you owned something of a comparable value—say, an expensive car, a house, a small yacht or a light aircraft—I’d guess that you would try to protect your property. So why can’t you afford the same protection for your head? There’s no denying that helmets are effective. In a study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, researchers found that wearing a helmet reduces “the risk of head injury by 85 percent and brain injury by 88 percent.” Injuries to your legs and arms can often be healed. But severe trauma to your head is far more dangerous. According to a report from 1996-2005 by the New York City Department of Transportation from, 97 percent of cyclists who died following an accident weren’t wearing a helmet. Every year, across America, hundreds of people die because “helmets are too expensive.” Because “helmets are uncomfortable.” Because “helmets can’t protect me.” I don’t mean to say that a helmet is some kind of panacea. Like wearing a seatbelt when you’re driving, donning a helmet will not immunize you against injury or prevent you from dying. Yet it is clear that wearing a helmet largely increases your chances of surviving an accident. Cycling accidents happen all the time and not just out on the street. Last year, I witnessed a student from Brunswick High School hit a squirrel while cycling at some speed across the Quad. He flipped over the handlebars and landed on the path. By some stroke of luck, he walked away with only a few scratches. I shudder to think what might have happened had he not been wearing a helmet. Let me be clear: I have nothing against cycling, nor do I wish to force helmets onto your heads. There’s nothing wrong about not wearing a helmet. You are all adults and are quite capable of making your own decisions. But all of you have exceptional minds: you are Bowdoin students after all. Wouldn’t it be an incredible shame if it all went to waste?
Whenever I see groups of visitors being led around campus on admissions tours, I wonder about the kinds of things that they must notice as they walk around Bowdoin’s campus. What do they think about the Quad? Do they think—as I do—that Smith Union is a little too bright and its colors a little too garish? Are they frightened by the thunder of basketball being played in Sargent Gym?
They inevitably will start thinking about the cost of going to a school like Bowdoin. Going to college in the United States isn’t cheap; Bowdoin is certainly no exception. So you will forgive my surprise when I see people racing around campus at breakneck speeds, endangering the brains they have invested in so dearly: helmet-wearing cyclists are few and far between at Bowdoin.
“Well if they don’t need to use their brains, they don’t need helmets!” quipped one professor who always wears a helmet when cycling. If we assume that the cost of a Bowdoin education is related to the value of your brain, then your cerebral matter is quite valuable indeed. For argument’s sake, let’s say that four years at Bowdoin costs $200,000. And let’s just say that this represents the approximate value of your brain. If you owned something of a comparable value—say, an expensive car, a house, a small yacht or a light aircraft—I’d guess that you would try to protect your property. So why can’t you afford the same protection for your head?
- November 15
One week ago, the staff of the Harvard Crimson ran an editorial embracing a new trend in higher education—the growing number of students choosing to pursue degrees in science, technology, engineering and mathematical (STEM) fields over the humanities. “Let them eat code” is currently the top-read article on the Crimson’s website, with 80 comments as of press time. The editorial applauds students who choose these more “rigorous” fields, characterizing the knowledge and skills gained through study of these disciplines as more practical in our ultra-competitive economy. Scholars in the humanities, they write, are of little importance because with or without them, people will still have access to literature, music and philosophy.
“Why spend four years listening to lecturers warn you that you can never really know anything?” asks the piece. We can’t help but note that this is neither an unenlightening nor a novel concept; Socrates argued that “the only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.”
And while we do not believe that four years spent reading Woolf and Hume and Shakespeare is a waste of time, the strength of a liberal arts education is, in part, its breadth. Bowdoin’s new Digital and Computational Studies Initiative proves that the two disciplines are not mutually exclusive; for one final project in the inaugural Gateway to the Digital Humanities class, two students are learning code to build a website that archives the history of art at the College. These classes prove that the disciplines are not only valuable in and of themselves but as complements to one another.
- November 15
Only Charcoal to Defend: From Guy Fawkes to Black Friday: Reconciling November’s holidays
November is the month when we descend into winter. Each holiday takes us a little deeper. The sun shone when the month was young, and Halloween parties peppered the campus. I got giddy when I saw a couple Guy Fawkes masks—a symbol of the internet hacktivist group Anonymous, of Occupy Wall Street, and of other anti-government and anti-establishment movements around the world. “We are legion!” yelled one masked Halloweener at one point, echoing the mantra of Anonymous.
I managed to remember the Fifth of November when it came. It received very little news coverage, but Twitter was full of pictures of protestors with Guy Fawkes masks in front of Buckingham Palace, the White House, and other symbols of power around the world. In 1605, Londoners lit bonfires all over the city to celebrate the foiling of Guy Fawkes’ gunpowder plot to blow up the House of Lords. To more and more people now, November 5 is a revolutionary day waiting for Fawkes’ reckoning.
But before I can romanticize a gunpowder plot, with November comes a day that is beautiful for many reasons, and would not tolerate more destruction. Kurt Vonnegut described how on November 11, 1918, “millions upon millions of human beings stopped butchering one another” and the First World War ended. The day was named Armistice Day, and never again were we supposed to have another war like the one that cease fire ended. The day is now known as Veterans Day—and we have had many wars since. Had Vonnegut and I been friends, we would have celebrated our birthdays together on this day, and maybe we would have talked about how we were never supposed to have such wars again.
- November 15
Climate distilled: $10/ton: Costs of offsetting your carbon guilt
If you could pay someone to erase your carbon footprint, would you do it?
Let me rephrase that: would you pay someone to erase your carbon footprint, even if you weren’t sure that it would work?
This is the fascinating, if contentious, promise of the carbon-offsetting industry.
- November 15
Kicking the can: Data dump: what new mathematical methods mean for social sciencesThanks to the work of popular social science authors like Steven Levitt of Freakonomics and Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight, data analysis is a hot new trend in social science. Unfortunately, not everyone can be a Silver or a Levitt. Objective, data-driven research can help to clarify much in the social sciences, but scientists who jump onto these new methods with little statistical training or rigor do their disciplines a disservice. Objective study is very important to social science, but so is traditional, subjective observation and we must remember that many of the social sciences were founded the development of regression analysis. Academics, and we who encounter their work, must be careful to receive statistical information with a health skepticism.“Correlation does not imply causation!” Anyone who has taken a statistics class or any data-driven course, has heard this phrase (often from a professor who is constantly peeved by people conflating the two concepts). Depending on the professor’s exasperation level, it is possible that she just finished reading a social science journal. Granted, it’s relatively rare that an article will openly claim causation where there’s none to be found, but implicit claims often lurk. And even in instances where causation is not claimed, some researchers dive no further into a topic after determining correlation. Correlation can tell us quite a lot, but we cannot pretend to understand an issue without determining the causes behind it.Correlative relationships are powerful rhetorical tools, and everyone from self-styled Facebook pundits to Ph.Ds use them to try to prove points. One familiar example is the oft-repeated claim that areas with high rates of gun ownership have comparably lower crime rates than those with lower gun ownership rates. This is true. But is it a causal relationship? Doubtfully. Areas with high gun ownership tend to be rural areas that would see low crime regardless of the size of its weapons cache—there are, after all, few multinational drug cartels in central Kansas. Just because the causal relationship is dubious doesn’t mean that it’s not great rhetoric. Correlative relationships provide fantastic material for argument, but many of these arguments demonstrate just why simple correlation shouldn’t be trusted as proof in academic research.Causal relationships are shown by revealing the relationship between correlated phenomena. Laboratory experiments are of limited value in the social sciences, so such relationships are explored by examining the effect of one thing on another in real world context.In many cases, researchers will accept statistical correlation as causation if there is a theoretical or cultural rationale for it—though they may sometimes do so to their own detriment. For instance, I recently read an academic paper detailing the relationship between a Paraguayan’s native language and her educational and economic achievement. The paper claimed that speaking Guaraní, the country’s most widely-spoken language, has measurable effect on—not just correlation with—achievement. This phenomenon is culturally possible—the Guaraní language has the stigmatized reputation as being backwards and less value than Spanish, the dominant language in Paraguay’s economy. However, the researchers failed to control for their subjects’ socioeconomic backgrounds. Socioeconomic background and language are no doubt strongly correlated, but both are also show strong correlation with achievement. Without controlling for that variable, among others, it is impossible to know whether Paraguayans’ mother tongues truly influence their economic or educational success.Cases like this bolster the argument that nuanced social and economic issues are perhaps better examined through more qualitative analyses than with complex mathematical models. Western social and political thought is to this day heavily influenced by the discoveries of the ancient Greeks and Romans; the great minds of these societies used little more than description and allegory to illustrate psychological and philosphical insights that remain relevant to this day. Political and social thinkers still cite Socrates’s allegory of the cave, for example, as an impressively illustrative of the way that distorted or incomplete information can create a gap between perception and reality. Émile Durkheim, who foundmodern sociology and shaped the structure of many modern social sciences, made these contributions to human understanding before mathematical analysis of huge data troves was de rigeur. Today’s social scientists would do well to remember that some of the best work done in their disciplines was completed without the use of sohpisticated mathematical models.Tim Groseclose, a professor at UCLA, observed that the social scientists who were mose effectively using quantitative methods often had a background in economics. I agree with Groseclose, but would expand this category to include all scientists with rigorous statistical or mathematical training. However, the researchers best at analyzing troves of data will not necessarily be those who produce the best results in social science. The social sciences need academics to interpret our world through logical analysis and thoughtful case studies and number-crunchers to filter through huge swaths of data and conduct rigorous analysis. What the fields do not need is flawed statistical study that contributes little to humanity’s understanding of itself.
Thanks to the work of popular social science authors like Steven Levitt of Freakonomics and Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight, data analysis is a hot new trend in social science. Unfortunately, not everyone can be a Silver or a Levitt.
Objective, data-driven research can help to clarify much in the social sciences, but scientists who jump onto these new methods with little statistical training or rigor do their disciplines a disservice. Objective study is very important to social science, but so is traditional, subjective observation and we must remember that many of the social sciences were founded the development of regression analysis.
Academics, and we who encounter their work, must be careful to receive statistical information with a health skepticism.
- November 15
Defending the cultural boycott: a response to Gabriel Frankel
Two weeks ago, journalist Ali Abunimah came to campus to give a talk on “The Battle for Justice in Palestine.” After the talk, he responded to the question of what average people can do to help alleviate the suffering of the Palestinians—suffering that is the result of apartheid, ethnic cleansing, and human and civil rights abuses. Abunimah called for people to take part in the call for a boycott of Israel, including PACBI (the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel).
Recently, Gabriel Frankel ’17 wrote a column in the opinion section criticizing the academic and cultural boycott of Israel for saying it repressed dialogue and singled out the state. Although Frankel cites USACBI throughout his article, I chose to cite PACBI because it is the actual movement that Frankel is referencing. USACBI is just a branch that supports PACBI, and both groups have the same call to action. I didn't read his article as a critique of USACBI specifically as an organization, but of the principles they stood for, which were created by PACBI in the first place. The USACBI website states "we are a U.S. campaign focused specifically on a boycott of Israeli academic and cultural institutions, as delineated by PACBI."
Frankel makes various disparate and blatantly incorrect claims regarding the motivations for PACBI—a call for action that the Palestinian community (including various trade unions and civil society groups) and many international organizations (such as the Green Party of the U.S., and hundreds of prominent academics) have officially endorsed.
Exploring two decades of the Leadership Training program at the Bowdoin Outing Club
For many students at Bowdoin, their outdoor experience will consist of an Outing Club trip, a few runs in the Brunswick Commons and, if they’re lucky, a trip to hike Mount Katahdin. But for students who seek more immersive outdoor experiences, the Bowdoin Outing Club (BOC) offers Leadership Training (LT) and its subgroup, Out of the Zone (OZ).
LT courses are offered in the fall, winter and spring.
According to the BOC webpage, LT participants are required to complete over 350 hours of lecture, demonstration and fieldwork to successfully complete the course and become certified to guide other students on trips.
Brunswick Farmers’ Market: the root of your locavore dinner
Every Tuesday and Thursday, fifteen local food vendors set up stalls along the Mall in downtown Brunswick to sell their day’s bounty. From seasonal produce to oven-fresh baked goods, the Brunswick Farmers’ Market provides a wide variety of local Maine fare. Every week, rain or shine, food enthusiasts come flooding to sample homegrown staples such as garlic-marinated goat cheese curds and hearty Sumatra roast coffee.
The market prides itself on being one of the oldest in the state—continuously operating for over 30 years. With friendly farmers and a tight-knit community, the vendors maintain a strong bond.
“We’re all competing, but it’s not cutthroat,” said Cathy Karonis, proprietor of Fairwinds Farm in Augusta. Over time, the farmers’ have fostered close bonds, due to each merchants’ commitment the long-term attendance.
Behind the Name tag: Catalogs and chords: library assistant Cook rocks ’n rolls
Students who frequent Hatch Science Library, whether they’re staffing the circulation desk or powering through a lab report, are probably familiar with Science Library Assistant Jeff Cook.
Now in his eighth year working at Bowdoin, Cook oversees many of the day-to-day operations of the library and is responsible for hiring, training and scheduling a staff of 20 to 25 students every semester.
Outside the library, Cook devotes a great deal of time to music. He plays drums and guitar for various bands in the area and has a small recording studio at his house that he claims to utilize often.
Relatively Quarky: New brain tumor identification technology, Tumor Paint, fluoresces hope for cancer patients
In 1888, William Williams Keen, the man who is considered to be the first neurosurgeon in the United States, successfully remove a malignant brain tumor.
Unsurprisingly, this moment is a watershed moment in the history of modern surgery. You can imagine that 125 years later, there would be many more radical and advanced methods of brain tumor removal.
However, the most significant change in surgical procedure may have just occurred.Since its invention, Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) has been giving surgeons an unprecedented level of detail into the structure of the human brain.
The bears and the bees: Pillow talk: let’s bring conversation to the bedroom
Americans are obsessed with sex. It’s everywhere—movies, magazines, billboards, even our classrooms—and we are constantly talking about it. We want to know how to have good sex, how to get a person to have sex with you, how to get someone to call you after a one-night stand, how to avoid making or receiving that call—the list goes on.
Sex is constantly in the conversation.
But for all the talking we do, there is very little discussion where it matters most: in the bedroom.
- November 15
Gateway to the Digital Humanities blends interfaces of digital world with humanities
A new course offered this semester, Gateway to the Digital Humanities, is the College’s first foray into the interdisciplinary Digital and Computational Studies Initiative (DCSI). Taught by Eric Chown and Pamela Fletcher, the heads of the computer science and art history departments respectively, the class was developed as a way to introduce humanitites students to the big data and computation that are becoming more prevalent every day.
Chown and Fletcher are the DCSI’s co-directors, while Director of the Quantitative Reasoning Program and Lecturer in Mathematics Eric Gaze, New Media and Data Visualization Specialist Jack Gieseking, and Postdoctoral Fellow in the Humanities Crystal Hall will teach DCSI courses next semester.
According to Gateway’s syllabus, the course “will explore the possibilities, limitations, and implications of using computation to study the humanities. What sorts of questions can be asked and answered using computational methods? How do these methods complement and sometimes challenge traditional methodologies in the humanities? What are the primary tools and methods currently being used in the digital humanities?”
- November 15
Talk of the Quad: Where there's a Wil: the story of Wil Smith '00
Wil Smith ’00 came very close to missing the first day of classes the fall of his first year at Bowdoin. At the end of August in 1996, he happened to be driving past campus and wondered when the semester was starting. He’d been accepted to the College the previous spring, but no longer lived at the address Bowdoin had on file from his application and had not received any preparatory material. So he was surprised when the deans informed him that classes began the next day.
He scrambled to make up for the time he’d lost in missing Orientation and began the semester with the rest of the student body that week. At 26-years-old, Wil was nearly a decade older than many of his new peers. When he showed up for his classes he brought an unannounced plus-one that caught his professors off-guard: his 16-month-old daughter, Olivia, who he was raising as a single father.
Professor Roy Partridge taught Wil’s First Year Seminar, “Racism.” He hid his surprise when Olivia and Wil came to class.
- November 15
Bottom of the Barrel: Tavernello Pinot Grigio: getting what you pay for
Trevor comes home from school.
“How was school?”
“Okay. We had a test.”
- November 15
Wrightly so: Jogging my way out of social obscurity: how Bowdoin got me healthy
Until recently, I had not been one for exercise. I had not been one for any form of movement, really. There was little I enjoyed more than sitting around doing absolutely nothing. In fact, there is still nothing I enjoy more than doing nothing. However, I now force myself over to the Buck Center six out of seven evenings to, as the kids say, “Lift, bro.”
To be honest, lifting is not actually a part of my routine. I just said that because I wanted to be cool, and I should be ashamed of myself. Nonetheless, it is true that I have incorporated going to the gym into my daily routine.
Some days ago it came to me in a dream that I should get in shape. In the dream I saw someone with a wonderfully ripped torso and excellent calves standing in front of a mirror. Even in the dream I knew that person was certainly not me, but I couldn’t help wishing he was. The little green monster of envy began to get to me.
- November 15
Talk of the Quad: A bathroom pitch: networking in the stalls
There is a Spartan feel to the men’s restroom in Smith Union. It has three reddish-brown stalls, three sinks and two urinals. The floor is an industrial sort of teal and remarkably clean for one of the most heavily trafficked bathrooms on campus. The walls are almost bare—unadorned except for the sheet of paper hanging above the leftmost urinal, advertising Sustainable Bowdoin’s strategies for being green.
Last time I used one of those urinals, I was reading that piece of paper for what felt like the third or fourth time. The poster boards in other parts of Smith are a veritable orgy of ever-changing color.
They advertise poetry readings and lectures, parties and candidates for student government. Yet despite this flashiness, these posters are rarely read.
Arts & Entertainment
Snapshot: Behind the radio: The WBOR studio
cinema scope: ‘12 Years a Slave’: imperfect and honest
Poor “12 Years a Slave.” In just three short months this film has fallen prey—if not to its own excellence—than least to critical perception of that excellence. Earlier this fall the film debuted at a series of North American festivals to near-universal praise. By my count, no fewer than 10 critics have declared the film this year’s presumptive Oscar Best Picture winner, and this was all long before the public was able to see the film.
Recently the film has drawn a swell backlash. Instead of “is it good?” critics are now asking, “how good is it, really?” Is director Steve McQueen’s depiction of slavery politically insightful or simply aesthetically detached? These are fruitful questions; this film is not perfect. But my point is that the sheer volume of judgment and critiques that preceded viewers’ experience robbed them of the opportunity to encounter it—for better or worse—it without preconception.
It’s dangerous and ultimately pointless for a critic to deem a film an Oscar winner in any context outside of an Oscar preview; the statement tells us nothing about the film’s content of intrinsic value. And given the past few years’ winners, such a prediction could even be considered a minor insult—if “12 Years a Slave” does take home an Oscar for Best Picture, it will be far and above the most intelligent and immersive film to do so in at least six or seven years, perhaps much longer.
Snapshot: Sounds of 1910
48-Hour Film Festival yields three student films
“Fast, exciting, creative,” were three words Bowdoin Film Society (BFS) co-President Monica Das ’14 used to describe last weekend’s 48-Hour Film Festival.
The Festival, which began in 2008, challenges students to dedicate a single weekend to making a movie. As the name of the festival implies, participants have only 48 hours to write, cast, shoot and edit a 10-minute film. Prizes for each movie are awarded at a screening the following weekend.
BFS co-President Isabelle Franks ’14 says that the festival provides a unique opportunity for students to get involved in filmmaking while at Bowdoin.
Eggert awarded Maine Art Commission Fellowship
Assistant Professor of Art Alicia Eggert recently received the Maine Art’s Commission 2014 Visual Arts Fellowship. This $13,000 award is the Commision’s largest unrestricted grant, awarded based on artistic excellence and merit.
Eggert has been on sabbatical this semester, and just completed a two-month artist residency in New York City through Sculpture Space.
The Maine Arts Commission, whose mission is to “encourage and stimulate public interest and cultural heritage of the state and assist freedom of public expression,” hosts an open round of applications for this fellowship, with different categories in including visual arts and performing/media arts.
Creation Theories: Inside the writing process of former Maine Poet Laureate Betsy Sholl
For Betsy Sholl, poetry is an exercise in ventriloquism. On the pages of her notebook—she starts each draft with pen and paper—she channels a voice different from the one that carried across the table to me in her cozy Portland kitchen. I had asked, perhaps unfairly, to what extent the voice of her poems is her own.
“I would hope on some level the voice is mine,” she laughed. “But I do try to get the first person pronoun out of my poems—I want to be an ‘eye’ more than a capital ‘I’.”
Sholl has not always emphasized such an observational voice. In her earlier years, her mouth overpowered her eye.
Portrait of an artist: Mik Cooper '14
If you ask Mik Cooper ’14 how she got into photography, she’ll tell you it was mostly by chance. At age 13, her father gave her his 35 mm film camera—a relic from the ’70s.
“From there I just started… developing photos and printing,” she said.
She started printing in her high school’s darkroom, working exclusively with black and white film. Then, she began to take darkroom classes at school, and later spent a few summers taking courses at the International Center for Photography in New York.
- November 15
LIVE MY LIEF: Manipulating Internet culture with optimism
Steve Roggenbuck, a 26-year-old rising Internet bard with nearly 15,000 Twitter followers, shared his work on campus last week.
Many of us have thought at one time, “My professor is wrong.” And some of us have felt the urge to abandon college and pursue something we are more passionate about. But few of us ever act on these moments. Steve Roggenbuck, a rising poet best known for his viral YouTube videos, did exactly that.
After completing a degree in English at Central Michigan University, Roggenbuck began courses at Columbia College Chicago for his Masters of Fine Arts (MFA) in Poetry. However, when his professors discouraged his more playful poetry—inspired by beat writers and Walt Whitman—he eventually dropped out.
- November 15
Snark Week: Spears and Jesus: The Comeback Kids
At 5:15 p.m. on Tuesday, I’m sitting in Moulton, discussing Britney Spears and Jesus. More specifically their collective comeback. I asked my dinner companion: What does Britney represent in 2013? What does the album title Britney Jean really mean? Is it an oblique reference to that time she and Justin Timberlake wore matching jean suits? Or is it because her middle name is Jean? Is it socially acceptable to purchase Britney’s 13th fragrance? Was it acceptable to purchase her 12th and 11th?
Then we started talking about Jesus. There’s a new musical out titled “SPEARS: The Gospel According to Britney.” Patrick Blute, the creator, claimed in a Fox News article that this will be “the greatest story ever told to the greatest music ever written.” Blute—a Columbia grad—is careful to say that the show is not meant to be rude. He assures us that the musical, “tells an essential story using fragments of pop culture in a non-offensive way.” Blute says the piece is meant to reconcile “the anxiety 20-somethings feel about living in a society that has thousands of statements and not much substance.”
The musical played to this key audience when it opened at Columbia before moving into New York City.
- November 15
Portrait of an artist: Daniel Eloy '15
Daniel Eloy ’15 is the type of person who will tell you his opinion about pretty much anything. When he met me in Smith Union, he had just rushed from the art studio; half-wearing a scarf, he immediately slumped into an armchair. His voice was barely audible over the rambunctious conversations in the Union, but his words had weight (and marked lack of pettiness) so I leaned in to catch everything.
Most recently, Eloy proposed and executed the much-discussed “We Stand With You” photo-installation in response to this fall’s bias incidents. His work involved taking and editing portraits of 544 students.
“I just wanted people to look at them and feel like there was a sense of community here even in the face of bias and hate,” said Eloy.
interactive: 'Mules are sterile:' A look at the 91-year rivalry between Bowdoin and Colby
“We see them in our sleep.”
This is how Ben Smith, Coach of the 1998 U.S. women’s hockey team, described the team’s Canadian rivals in an interview with the New York Times leading up to their Olympic matchup.
It’s fair to guess that some Bowdoin hockey players may spend tonight similarly fixated on an opponent from the North, though the rival in question is Colby, not Canada. Today the Polar Bears will defend the first of last year’s decisive victories over the Mules. The rivalry between the two teams is a classic grudge match, and this year’s games continue a long and storied tradition.
Field Hockey plays Christopher Newport University in Final Four today
The field hockey team will play in the NCAA D-III Final Four this weekend in Virginia Beach after topping New Paltz State and Montclair State last weekend. Bowdoin takes on Christopher Newport University at 11 a.m. today for the right to advance to the national championship game against the winner of the game between Salisbury and Skidmore.
The Polar Bears return to the national semifinals for the seventh time in the last nine years, having claimed the Division III title in ’07, ’08 and ’10.
On Friday, the Polar Bears faced New Paltz State in the second round of the tournament, securing a 5-2 win over the Hawks. Less than five minutes into the game, Rachel Kennedy ’16 fed a long pass to Emily Simonton ’15, who wristed the shot just inside the left post, giving Bowdoin an early lead. Despite New Paltz taking three consecutive corners, the Polar Bears were able to counter each and preserve the lead. Before the end of the first half, Katie Riley ’14 added an unassisted shot to bring the lead up to 2-0.
Women's hockey gears up for opening match against Colby
Men's hockey struggles in their opening weekend
The men’s hockey team, defending NESCAC Champion, is still looking for a win this season after an opening weekend of mixed results. The Polar Bears tied Middlebury 2-2 last Friday, before losing to Williams 5-2 the following Sunday.
The team started out with an early lead in Friday’s game against Middlebury, with Kendall Culbertson ’17 scoring a transition goal—his first as a Polar Bear—at the 12-minute mark. Middlebury responded with a goal of its own less than two minutes into the second period, and within 15 minutes, the Panthers took the lead with another quick goal.
Roughly halfway into the third period, John McGinnis ’15 managed to tie the game, sending it into overtime. Neither team was able to score in the extra frame.
NESCAC Coach of the Year Marissa O'Neil '05 enters fourth season with high hopes
Head Coach of the women’s hockey team, Marissa O’Neil ’05, began playing hockey at age four. She grew up in Manchester, New Hampshire, where she practiced on the rink in her back yard. She was always the only girl on her hockey teams until she was 16.
She continued playing hockey in high school. After attending Kimball Union Academy in Meriden, New Hampshire, she applied and came to Bowdoin as a student athlete, playing both ice and field hockey. She was coached by current Head Coach Nicky Pearson in field hockey. O’Neil received several athletic awards while at Bowdoin. For field hockey, she received the Rookie of the Year award in 2001, the NESCAC Player of the Year award in 2003, a First Team All-American, and was a three-time First Team All-NESCAC selection. As an ice hockey player, she was named to the 2003 NCAA Division III All-Tournament team, and was a three-time All-NESCAC honoree.
Additionally, she received the Lucy L. Shulman Award in 2005, which is given to the most outstanding female athlete of the year.
Women’s soccer eliminated from NCAA tournament
Though the women’s soccer team captured its first NCAA D-III Tournament win since 1999 this past Saturday, it was eliminated from the competition on Sunday after falling 7-0 to regional host Montclair State.
The Polar Bears finished their regular season seeded third in the conference at 11-2-1 (7-2-1 NESCAC) but lost to Tufts in the NESCAC quarterfinals. However, the team’s season continued two weeks later after earning an at-large bid to the NCAA tournament.
Bowdoin drew Christopher Newport University, which boasted a 14-3-2 record, on Saturday for its first-round matchup. The game was close from the start, with both sides fighting to take a first-half lead. The Polar Bears very nearly took the lead 15 minutes in, as winger Abby Einwag ’15 let a shot rip from the left of the goal, forcing CNU goalkeeper Haley Casanova to make a diving stop.
Athlete of the Week: John Swords '15
John Swords ’15 set the bar high after his strong play in the Regis College Tip-Off Tournament, averaging 14.5 points per game and 11 rebounds in two games. His effort was enough to win the tournament’s Most Valuable Player award.
The seven-foot center created mismatches for the opposing teams, neither of whom had a player of comparable size. While NESCAC opponents are more likely to have players who can defend Swords, he is still the tallest player in the conference.
Swords started playing basketball in elementary school but gave it up to play hockey, following the lead of his two brothers. After ninth grade, he stopped playing and resumed basketball because he questioned his skating ability. Even at that time he was almost seven feet tall, including skates. Swords started working on improving his basketball skills, practicing with his best friend over the summer. He played very little during his first year with the team, but saw more time as a high school junior, and earned a captainship as a senior.
Kutztown ends women’s rugby’s run in Elite Eight
The women’s rugby team began its final weekend of play last Saturday by knocking off Hamilton 39-22 in the Sweet 16 round of American College Rugby Associaton (ACRA) national tournament play before falling to Pennsylvania’s Kutztown University in the Elite Eight.
“Hamilton came ready to blow us away,” said Head Coach MaryBeth Mathews. “The game was a lot closer than the final score makes it look.”
The Polar Bears opened scoring in the 14th minute of play when Samantha Hoegle ’17 sprinted past Hamilton’s defense. Just 10 minutes later the Continentals drove back to score a try of their own, bringing the score to 5-5. Hoegle scored again six minutes later, followed by another try from Amanda Montenegro ’14. After a Hamilton try, Addison Carvajal ’16 scored at the end of the first half.
D-III Regionals have mixed results for cross country teams
For the men’s and women’s cross-country teams, hopes ran high at the University of Southern Maine this past weekend. Both teams competed in the NCAA Regional Championships, where a strong finish could have improved their respective rankings and ensure each team a bid for the National Championships. Though the teams fell a bit short of expectations—the men were just one place shy of finishing in a position to earn a bid to Nationals—Head Coach Peter Slovenski said that the Polar Bears have much to be proud of.Women
The women’s team—originally seeded 14th in the New England regional polls—finished the competition in 11th place.“Four of the women’s team runners ran personal best times. They took advantage of the big race atmosphere and used the crowd to help them run their best,” said Slovenski. Runners who achieved personal records included Lucy Skinner ’16, who finished ninth with a time of (21:35.23), which shattered her previous best time by a full 60 seconds, and Brenna Fischer ’15, who beat her previous best by 20 seconds, turning in a time of 23:42.02. First years Gillian Kramer and Caroline Corban also ran personal best races, finishing with times of 23:42.02 and 23:30.12, respectively.Skinner started off at 40th place in the first mile, but moved up to 23rd by the end of the second. She shot up to fourth place in mile three to end in ninth overall.“Our coach does a good job at making sure we peak at the right time,” said Skinner. “Also, my teammates were really supportive and a lot of people were cheering. It just all came together”“Lucy showed the best composure,” Slovenski added. “She stayed relaxed and accelerated throughout the race. It’s hard to pass other runners in high level races, but she passed 14 all-star runners in the final two miles.”Senior captain Madelena Rizzo was another standout; her time of 22:14:04 was the second fastest posted by a Polar Bear and earned her 32nd place in the meet. Rizzo and Skinner both earned places on the All-New England team and Skinner’s personal best was enough to qualify her for the NCAA National Championship in Indiana.“Our coach does a good job at making sure we peak at the right time. Also my teammates were really supportive and a lot of people were cheering. It just all came together”Coach Slovenski said another contributor to Skinner’s success was the ease with which she approached the race.“Lucy showed the best composure. She stayed relaxed and accelerated throughout the race,” Slovenski said. “It’s hard to pass other runners in high level races, but she passed 14 all-star runners in the final two miles.”Men
The men’s team was seeded fifth but ended the day in seventh place.“Some other teams did a better job of peaking,” Slovenski said. “We ran pretty well, but we didn’t have a great peak at the regional as we usually do”Captain Sam Seekins ’14 agreed with Slovenski.“We were hoping to be at least top five to qualify for nationals…Enough guys on the team had an off day to where we ended up being edged off by Colby and Bates, both of whom we had beaten earlier in the season, but they unfortunately beat us in the most important race,” he said.Despite the team-wide disappointment, the men still enjoyed some successes at the meet. For example, captain Coby Horowitz ’14, Nick Saba ’14 and Seekins all achieved all-New England team honors.Horowitz, the team’s top runner, finished fourth in the 8K with a time of 24:42:18. He ran most of the race in eighth position at the rear of the front pack. He moved up to sixth with a mile to go and passed two more runners to finish in fourth place.Other Bowdoin runners found themselves in the top 60. Seekins placed 28th, turning in a time of 25:21:81; Saba was 34th (25:30:81), and Kevin Hoose ’15 placed 55th (26:00:15) with Greg Talpey ’14 close behind at 56th (26:00:44).Horowitz will join Skinner at the NCAA Championship at Hanover College in Indiana tomorrow.
Women’s basketball starts hot at 3-0
The women’s basketball team opened its season by winning the Salem Tip-Off Tournament at Salem State last weekend, defeating Norwich 66-55 and Salem State 81-49. The Polar Bears carried this momentum to their home opener on Tuesday, beating Endicott 67-56.
Head Coach Adrienne Shibles cited the team’s improved chemistry and fitness as reasons for the early success.
“Our chemistry has always been solid, but this year it’s exceptional,” Shibles said. “They’re all on the same page in terms of where we want to go this season, which makes my job as coach easier.”