In a dramatic performance on Saturday, the NESCAC’s eighth-seeded Polar Bears defeated first-seeded Tufts 60-54 in the first round of the NESCAC tournament, improving their record to 14-10 and handing Tufts (23-2) their second loss of the season.

It was a historic upset, the first time in NESCAC women’s basketball history that the bottom seed has toppled the top seed.     

The Polar Bears have a history of excellence in the NESCAC championships. Never ranked lower than fifth in tournament history, Bowdoin won the first seven NESCAC titles and has made it to the final round nine times in 12 years.

Forced to rebuild after the graduation of a large senior class last spring, the young Polar Bears snuck into the tournament by beating Connecticut College in the final game of the season.

“No one expected us to make it a close game, let alone win it,” said Captain Kaitlin Donahoe ’13. “All season our coaches have been telling us ‘just get into the playoffs and anything can happen,’ and we made it by the skin of our teeth.”

For the first time in program history, the Polar Bears are the underdogs in the NESCAC tournament.

“I think the whole school has embraced it,” Donahoe said. “I’ve had more people, who I didn’t even know followed us, come up to me this week and say congratulations. Everyone loves an underdog. It was easy to look at it as a negative thing at first, seeing that we weren’t in the top four where we would have usually been, but now it’s empowering knowing that no one gave us any chance to beat Tufts. It’s bringing us together closer as a team.”

After clinching their playoff berth, the team had a week of rest before facing Tufts, the seventh-ranked team in the nation.

 “We needed to put everything that had happened, good and bad behind us and just consider it a fresh start,” said Head Coach Adrienne Shibles. “If we played to our potential, we had a good chance to win.”

“The week going into Tufts, we focused on the belief that we could do it and play execution,” said Donahoe.

Though being the eighth seed took some of the pressure off of the Polar Bears, each match from now on feels like a matter of life or death. 

 “We know if we lose, we’re done,” said Donahoe. “Amherst and Tufts are going to go on to the NCAAs, win or lose. It’s win or go home. It’s fueled us even more to not take a play off, to bring intensity and to talk to every play, to do all the little things that we talk about day in and day out.”

Earlier in the season, the Polar Bears were hammered by Tufts 62-44.  The Polar Bears lost their composure against the Jumbo’s intense defense, giving up 20 turnovers. 

“Tufts is one of the best defensive teams in the nation,” said Shibles. “The first time we played them they got a lot of steals and forced turnovers from doubling us or collapsing on us in the paint.”

On Saturday, Shibles said she felt that her team gave up too many turnovers in the first half but was able to tighten up ball control after halftime.      
    
“Their defensive pressure didn’t rattle us this time,” said Shibles. “We talked about being strong with the ball: ‘They’re going to be all over us trying to get their hands on the ball.’”
“We were a little fearful the first time we played them since we had never really faced a NESCAC defense,” said Donahoe. “I didn’t see that intimidation or fear from anyone this past weekend.”

Bowdoin looked to draw out Tufts’  quickly shifting defense and double team traps in the paint, allowing them to move the ball to the players on the weak side.

The Polar Bears shot excellently from the perimeter, sinking 11 of 19 3-pointers, often with the obstruction of a Jumbo defender’s hand. Bowdoin sunk 57.9 percent of its 3-pointers, while Tufts made just 19 percent.  

“They were definitely pressure shots,” said Donahoe. “In practice, we picked up the defensive intensity against each other, and I think that has translated really well into games.”

Ultimately, the match was an offensive team effort with balanced scoring. Selena Lorrey ’16 led Bowdoin with 11 points off the bench.

“It was clear she was really mentally ready to go,” said Shibles. “You could just tell she was really feeling it behind the arc; she has a lot of confidence in her shot.”

Tufts scored the bulk of its points from up close.

“Their posts are very guard-like—they’re dangerous because they can take you off the dribble and shoot,” said Shibles.

At halftime, the Polar Bears led Tufts by six, but there was no celebration or break of focus in the Bowdoin locker room.  

“We immediately started talking about things that we could do better,” said Donahoe. “We’ve been in this situation before where we got that complacent feeling. We didn’t want that to happen again since we knew the Tufts coach was going to be in their face. As much as it stunk going through hardships in the regular season, I think we’ve learned from them and they are helping us out now.” 

The Polar Bears will make their 13th straight appearance in the NESCAC semifinals tomorrow, facing the NESCAC’s No. 2 and nationally sixth-ranked Amherst. The Polar Bears will travel to Amherst, Mass., where the Lady Jeffs hold a 77-game winning streak at home. 

Bowdoin lost to Amherst 74-58 in the regular season on January 18. The Polar Bears led by six at halftime but fell apart in the second half when the Jeffs amped up their defense. 
The Polar Bears are more excited to face Amherst coming off the confidence boost from the Tufts-upset, according to Lorrey. Donahoe categorized this week’s practices as “most positive and uplifting.”   

“We’re focusing a lot on limiting their second-chance opportunities,” said Donahoe. “They got a lot of offensive rebounds and put-backs, and we bailed them out a lot sending them to the line. After looking at film we saw there were a few sets where they continually scored on us with the exact same play six to eight times. So were focusing on what we need to do to shut down their strengths.”

The last time Amherst developed a large home win streak—a 25-game run in 2009—it was the Polar Bears who snapped it. Tomorrow, they hope to do this again. 

“We feel if we continue to play the way we played this past weekend, we can beat anyone, and it is fun to be the spoiler,” said Shibles.